Beautiful boots with lots of good wear still left. There are some scratches and scuffs on the toes, and one boot has few smudges of some gray paint which I could not get off easily, but I didn’t try using a paint remover, just my fingernail. Leather still supple, stitching is bright. Soles are still in excellent condition. Smoke-free home. Let me know if you have any questions. Size 11D.